Lessons in morality from Egyptian media
 
 

Videos of a curly-haired woman pushing and yelling at a police officer at Cairo airport took social media by storm earlier this month. Yasmine al-Narsh, who is from a wealthy and powerful family, has since been detained on charges of drug possession, which many believe the police framed her for.

This story has several intriguing elements, such as the clash of power between security and the wealthy, as well as leveling fabricated charges against citizens for certain crimes. However, many media outlets were more interested in investigating her lifestyle after the outburst, given that she used language perceived as inappropriate for her social standing. Several websites published pictures from Narsh’s Facebook account, showing her in revealing clothes and drinking at parties, labelling them as “shocking.”

The way in which the media handled this case is not far removed from the general approach of various television hosts and prominent media personalities, who take it upon themselves to be agents of morality. They use their public platforms to preach to viewers on what’s right and wrong, and at times feel obliged to set their guests straight when they don’t approve of their moral choices. Here are examples of other incidents in which Egyptian media has sought to preach morality to the populace.

Tamer Amin cracks his knuckles at Inas al-Degheidy

Tamer Amin and Inas al-Degheidy

Tamer Amin and Inas al-Degheidy

Last month, Tamer Amin dedicated ten minutes of his nightly talk show to respond to film director Inas al-Degheidy’s statement expressing a belief that sex outside of marriage is not a sin.

Amin maintained a look of disgust throughout, cracking his knuckles and neck and pausing to exhale deeply in a show of suppressed rage.

He opened the episode with, “As usual, on this show we talk about respect, ideals, what’s permissible in religion and what’s not, what’s appropriate and what’s not.”

Amin said he respects people’s personal freedoms and only criticizes them when they call for immoral acts in public.

He did focus on Degheidy’s personal life, however, showing a headshot of her and commenting that the team couldn’t show a wider angle, and suggesting that she dresses too revealingly.

He also speculated that she addresses sex frequently in her work and media appearances because of a personal complex related to sex and sarcastically asked the audience to pray for her, in the hope that God leads her towards the right path.

Amin finally asserted that Degheidy’s statement is a crime and called on the authorities to punish her.

“Why have we become so shameless and loose?” he lamented.

Mona Hala is interrogated by two talk show hosts

Pictures posted by young Egyptian actress Mona Hala, who lives in the US, on her personal Instagram account spurred a local media storm against her.

The young actress couldn’t have foreseen the amount of media interest that pictures she posted of herself in a bikini at the beach, or being intimate with her boyfriend, would garner.

In a visit to Egypt last month, Hala appeared on a talk show on the newly launched Ten Channel with hosts Ramy Radwan and Injy Anwar. The interview quickly turned into a moral court case.

It began when Anwar gave Hala a shocked look and turned her head away in dismay when the latter mentioned that she had a boyfriend.

Radwan and Anwar then argued back when Hala explained that she felt she was free to make personal choices, asking her why she’s not married, whether or not her family advised her to change her behavior, and whether she worries that producers might not want to work with her anymore. They ended by asking her if she was planning on repeating the same mistakes.

To demonstrate that principles are relative, Hala explained that she’s vegetarian and that, for her, killing animals to eat is a crime, but that she doesn’t judge the majority of Egyptians who disagree with her.

Anwar immediately dismissed her argument, claiming that vegetarianism is a luxury, while Egyptian traditions are not to be tampered with.

Mohamed Amin protects journalism from nightgowns

In his column in Al-Masry Al-Youm entitled “The newscast in a night gown,” published earlier this month, Mohamed Amin warns that satellite stations are no longer in harmony with “Egypt’s character,” because they permit female presenters to go on air in sleeveless shirts, which he claims are “similar to night gowns.”

“Is the competition about making female presenters take off their clothes?” he asks, adding, “One presenter uses flashy colors and is not pleasant to look at, either in terms of her clothes or her make-up, another lets her hair loose on her back and her face, another cuts it in a disgusting way. Who allowed them to appear on air like this? Every woman is free to wear what she wants, but not to appear like this as a presenter.”

He concludes by pointing out that being a presenter shuould not be confused with modelling.

Reham Saeed kicks the atheist out

It was quite confusing when talk show host Reham Saeed invited an atheist onto her show last year and then proceeded to shout at her, ultimately kicking her out of the studio.

Instead of exploring the woman’s views, Saeed dismissed all her arguments. When the woman attempted to discuss her beliefs, including her conviction that the Quran was written by humans, Saeed repeatedly interrupted her angrily, warning her: “Stop saying this, or I will remove it from the edit.”

When the guest said she believed that the Prophet Mohamed did not receive teachings from God and that he made them up, Saeed lost it. “You are the one making things up, you’re speaking out of ignorance,” she fumed.

When the guest threatened to walk out if her host insulted her once more, Saeed was quick to respond: “Get out, I wasted my time talking to a lunatic.”

Basma Wahba is “shocked and disgusted” by transgender women

Basma Wahba

Basma Wahba

Talk show host Basma Wahba’s judgment was focused on transgender women in an episode she described as “documenting a weird, bizarre and unnatural reality.”

Wahba repeatedly asserted that an episode shot in Lebanon was focused on transgender women engaging in sex work, and not on those who she said need the operation for medical reasons.

She congratulated herself on her professionalism: “I decided to neutralize my feelings and work professionally, despite the fact that I was shocked and disgusted by their gestures and their clothes and the way they looked. I was about to back out, but decided to continue working amid these scenes.”

Wahba reinforced widely held societal beliefs that sex changes are the result of childhood trauma, randomly asking each of her guests whether they had been sexually assaulted as a child and whether they had a stable family life.

She described one case as “comical” as the mother had approved of her child’s decision to have a sex change.

Wahba insisted on alternating between addressing her transgender guests as male and female, and when one objected, she asked, “Am I offending your femininity?” The guest replied, “Yes, wouldn’t you be offended?” to which Basma retorted, “Yes, but I was never a man.”

At one point, she taunted a guest, Nicole (previously known as Nagy), referring to her by her previous name after she objected. “Well, you’re a transsexual, what do you want them to think of you? And before you were Nicole you were Nagy, What’s up Nagy? What’s up?” Wahba asked.

She considered her guests to have “given away their manhood” and lamented the loss of moral values in these decisions.

When all of Wahba’s guests said that they had undergone sexual reassignment surgery after a lifetime of feeling they were in the wrong body, Wahba said, “They all say they felt disfigured before, but it’s not true. They had the surgery to become more beautiful, as if we don’t know it’s artificial beauty.”

Wahba said she could not think why men would go for transgender women and she expressed her bewilderment at two of her guests, who were engaged to be married.

“There are plenty of girls in this world, why would he go for a transsexual who can’t give him kids?” she asked.

In the end, science will have to reveal that they are “sick,” she concluded, with a last piece of advice for men who fall for transgender women: “Look what recklessness can result in — you could end up with a man. It’s all because we stopped listening to our parents. Stop being so careless about your future and listen to your parents, at least they won’t choose a transsexual for you. Now you know the value of arranged marriages.”

AD
 
 
 
 

You have a right to access accurate information, be stimulated by innovative and nuanced reporting, and be moved by compelling storytelling.

Subscribe now to become part of the growing community of members who help us maintain our editorial independence.
Know more

Join us

Your support is the only way to ensure independent,
progressive journalism
survives.